Students Put Sales Skills to the Test in First-Ever Montana Fastenal Competition

Photos of Fastenal Sales Competition

Hands-on competition brings industry professionals into the classroom, giving students real-world experience in sales strategy, problem-solving, and client relationships.

Students in Carroll College’s Professional Sales class traded textbooks for sales pitches this November as they stepped into the roles of professional sales representatives, presenting business solutions to industry experts in a competition designed to mirror the challenges of real-world sales.

The Fastenal Student Sales Competition, held November 10 at Carroll College, brought representatives from Fastenal, a national business-to-business (B2B) industrial supply and supply chain solutions company, to campus to evaluate student sales presentations, provide professional feedback, and identify emerging talent.

While Fastenal hosts similar competitions at colleges and universities across the country, this marked the company's first student sales competition in Montana, offering Carroll students a unique opportunity to apply classroom learning in a professional setting.

The experience began in late September when Fastenal representatives visited Associate Professor of Marketing Annette Ryerson's Professional Sales class to introduce the competition and outline the challenge. Over the next five weeks, students worked in teams of two or three to research the company, develop sales strategies, and prepare presentations designed to convince a prospective customer to invest in Fastenal's inventory management technology.

Rather than simply selling a product, students were challenged to understand a customer's operational problems and demonstrate how a proposed solution could improve efficiency, reduce costs, and streamline business operations.

In a scenario developed specifically for the competition, students assumed the roles of Fastenal sales professionals pitching an automated inventory management solution to Carroll College's facilities department. The sales scenario challenged students to address common operational inefficiencies, including difficulties maintaining accurate inventory levels, delays in obtaining necessary supplies, and time lost to purchasing and inventory management.

The assignment required more than a polished presentation. Students had to anticipate objections, respond to questions in real time, communicate the financial value of their recommendations, and ultimately ask for the sale.

“One of the reasons Fastenal loves partnering with colleges on competitions like this is because it gives students a chance to step outside the classroom, challenge themselves, and experience a real-world business situation,” said Kerrie Scott, Regional Recruiter for Fastenal. “I really enjoyed watching the students build confidence throughout the experience and connect with Fastenal professionals who were there to encourage and support them.”

On competition day, O'Connell Hall was host to a series of mock sales meeting rooms. Teams, many dressed in blue to reflect Fastenal's corporate branding, delivered 15-minute sales pitches to Fastenal managers playing the roles of prospective customers. Each presentation was followed by a five-minute feedback session, giving students direct insight into their performance from Fastenal professionals who regularly have these conversations in their own professional lives.

The Fastenal team included regional recruiters from San Diego and Seattle, along with regional and district managers from Butte, Missoula, and Great Falls. Their involvement gave students the opportunity to interact with professionals representing different aspects of the company's sales operations and learn what employers look for in successful sales representatives.

"I am so grateful to Fastenal for bringing a customized sales competition to the Carroll College classroom,” said Dr. Ryerson. “This was such a meaningful, hands-on competition, giving the students direct contact with eight members of the Fastenal team. The students learned invaluable lessons that extended far beyond the classroom. I look forward to similar opportunities in the future. This is what learning is all about!"

For students, the experience offered something difficult to replicate through traditional coursework: the opportunity to test their preparation and communication skills in an unpredictable, high-pressure business conversation. Success depended not only on knowing the product but also on listening carefully, thinking on their feet, building trust, and demonstrating a clear understanding of the customer's needs.

“One of my biggest takeaways was the importance of building a relationship with the customer rather than just trying to make a sale,” said Emily Barnett, a junior from Aurora, Oregon, majoring in Business Accounting and Strategic Finance, whose team won third place. “My partner and I focused on understanding the product instead of memorizing a script so we could listen, ask questions, and find solutions that fit the customer’s needs. I really enjoyed working together and building on each other’s strengths throughout the conversation.”

Following the presentations, Fastenal representatives deliberated and selected the top three teams. The first-place team received $500, second place earned $300, and third place received $250, with prize money divided among team members. The event concluded with an awards presentation and networking opportunities, allowing students to connect with Fastenal representatives and learn more about internships and career opportunities within the company.

“Our team was so impressed with the Carroll College students,” shared Scott.  “They came prepared, were professional, asked great questions, and weren’t afraid to step outside their comfort zones. Their energy and willingness to learn really stood out to us. We’re excited to continue building our partnership with Carroll College and supporting these students as they take the next steps in their careers.”

Carroll is grateful to Fastenal for bringing this unique opportunity to campus and investing in the professional development of our students. Partnerships like this demonstrate the important role experiential learning plays in a Carroll education, connecting classroom knowledge with real-world experience and providing students with the skills, confidence, and professional connections that will serve them well beyond graduation.

Winning Teams:

1st place winner
1st place: Jon Slivinski & Ethan Lyle
2nd Place Winner
2nd place: Harley Jackson & Brandon Bliss 
3rd Place Winner
3rd place: Victoria Krantz & Emily Barnett